In the long human habit of handing power from one leader to the next, a former president has now chosen to set down, in his own memoir, the letter his predecessor left him and the friendly words spoken across a table years later. Joe Biden presents these fragments as evidence of a puzzling duality, a man who seemed to speak in two registers at once. The reactions from his former rival's camp and from the aides who surrounded both men show how quickly such private courtesies become public arguments. What the record ultimately means will depend on whether readers see gracious ritual, sincere fee
Biden Says Trump's Post-Riot Letter Showed 'Two Donald Trumps' in New Memoir
As if there were two Donald Trumps
Why does a thank-you-style letter from four years ago matter now?
Because Biden is presenting it as evidence of a puzzle. He says the Trump who wrote it didn't match the Trump who skipped the traditional meeting and, in his view, damaged democracy.
And the 2024 meeting adds to that?
It does. Biden describes Trump as chatty, almost fawning, and quotes him saying they'd be good friends if it weren't for politics.
Worth noting that the 2024 quote comes through The Atlantic's report on the book, and the letter text is as Biden reprints it. We haven't seen the full book, and Trump's side of those conversations isn't in the reporting.
What was the criticism of Biden at the time?
Charlamagne Tha God asked how Biden went from calling Trump an existential threat to welcoming him back, even while saying he was glad the transfer was peaceful.
That's one commentator's question, not a finding. It shows the tension some people saw, nothing more.
How did Trump's side respond?
Steven Cheung said Biden should have heeded the president's words and called him a disgrace. Theo Wold called the letter magnanimous and accused Biden of suggesting insincerity.
Both are partisan responses, and Wold is a former Trump aide. Also, Biden's office hasn't replied, so we don't know how he'd answer them.
The Pulse
- A warm letter from Trump, reprinted by Biden, collides with the picture of a man he says had destabilized democracy.
- Biden's account of a fawning 2024 Oval-era meeting has sparked questions about how a stated threat to democracy became a cordial welcome.
- The White House's sharp rebuke, calling Biden a disgrace, pushes the memoir excerpts into a partisan fight before the book even ships.
- Trump-aligned aides dismiss the letter as magnanimous and accuse Biden's ghostwriters of bias, leaving the dispute unsettled.
- Biden's office has not responded, and the full text of the book next week is poised to decide which reading the public accepts.
In the long human habit of handing power from one leader to the next, a former president has now chosen to set down, in his own memoir, the letter his predecessor left him and the friendly words spoken across a table years later. Joe Biden presents these fragments as evidence of a puzzling duality, a man who seemed to speak in two registers at once. The reactions from his former rival's camp and from the aides who surrounded both men show how quickly such private courtesies become public arguments. What the record ultimately means will depend on whether readers see gracious ritual, sincere feeling, or something harder to name.
When Joe Biden entered the White House in January 2021, a letter from Donald Trump was waiting for him. In his forthcoming memoir, "Promise Me, America," Biden reprints the note in full and says it struck him as strangely warm, as if two different Donald Trumps had written and behaved. The letter, sent weeks after the Capitol riot, urged Biden to choose his place in history and closed with a blessing for him, his wife and America.
Biden also recounts the customary 2024 meeting with the president-elect, where Trump was chatty and so friendly that Biden wondered whether he was being played. According to the account, Trump said that if not for politics they would be good friends and would spend their time golfing. Commentators pointed out the tension with Biden's own campaign warnings that Trump threatened democracy, with one radio host asking how someone goes from existential threat to "Welcome back."
The White House, through communications director Steven Cheung, rejected the portrayal, calling Biden a disgrace. Former Trump aide Theo Wold called the letter magnanimous and accused Biden of using it to suggest insincerity. Biden's office had not replied to requests for comment. With the book due next week, readers will be able to judge the letter and both meetings for themselves.
When Joe Biden walked into the White House in January 2021, a letter from his predecessor was waiting for him. According to Biden's forthcoming memoir, "Promise Me, America," it was warmer than he expected. Excerpts reported Tuesday show that Biden reprinted the note in full, and that the contrast between the letter and the man who wrote it stayed with him. The New York Times obtained the excerpt, and the book is due out next week.
The letter arrived weeks after the January 6 Capitol riot. Biden writes that it seemed as if there were two Donald Trumps. One, in his telling, had deeply destabilized American democracy and had declined to offer the traditional meeting between outgoing and incoming presidents. The other was the author of a letter that, Biden says, offered best wishes in language that sounded like it came from an old friend.
As Biden reproduces it, Trump wrote: "You now have the opportunity to choose your place in history, and I know you will be true to yourself and the American people." He went on to say that many presidents had simply governed as Republicans or Democrats and, for the most part, had not changed history but had been swept along in its tide. That, he told Biden, would not happen to him, because of how much Biden loved the American people. He also wrote that Biden's strength came from knowing that millions of people were depending on him, and closed with: "May God bless you and Jill, and may God bless America!"
The Atlantic highlighted a second passage, about the customary White House meeting in 2024 between Biden and the returning president-elect. Biden writes that Trump was immediately chatty and adopted a tone so friendly that Biden wondered whether he was being put on. It bordered on fawning, he says. According to the Atlantic's report, Trump told him: "You know, Joe, if it weren't for politics, I believe we'd be good friends," and added that they would spend all their time golfing together.
Biden's own demeanor at that 2024 meeting drew attention at the time. He had repeatedly described Trump during the campaign as a threat to democracy. Radio host Charlamagne Tha God raised the point on his show, saying he was glad the transfer of power was peaceful but asking what had happened to the talk of a threat to democracy and of fascism. He noted that he had said such things about Trump himself, but argued the words carry more weight coming from a political opponent like Biden. He asked how one goes from calling someone an existential threat to saying "Welcome back."
The White House responded to the memoir excerpts through communications director Steven Cheung, in a statement to Fox News Digital. Cheung said Biden should have heeded the president's wise words, but instead tried to destroy the country and weaponize the justice system against political enemies. He called Biden a disgrace and said America is better off with him out of office.
Theo Wold, who served as a deputy assistant for domestic policy in Trump's first-term White House, also spoke to Fox News Digital. He described the letter as magnanimous and said it impressed on Biden the weight of the job. Wold argued that Biden uses it only to tear Trump down by suggesting insincerity. He also accused Democrats, including what he called a team of leftist ghostwriters behind the book, of wanting to hate Trump regardless of evidence.
Fox News Digital contacted Biden's office for comment and had not received a response. With the book's release days away, the full text of the letter and the accounts of both meetings will soon be available for readers to weigh against the reactions already coming in.
Notable Quotes
Joe Biden should have heeded the President's wise words, but instead he tried to destroy this country and weaponize the justice system against his political enemies.— Steven Cheung, White House communications director
You know, Joe, if it weren't for politics, I believe we'd be good friends.— Trump, as quoted by Biden in The Atlantic's report