AUKUS Inquiry Scepticism Runs One Way, Argues Lowy Commentary on China Threat Assumptions

One superpower is in decline, the other on the rise; be wary of both.
The commentary's author urges 'dual scepticism' rather than doubting only Washington.
Mark

What is the commentary actually objecting to in the inquiry report?

Mimi

Its imbalance. The report questions US motives at length but, the author says, barely examines the assertions about China that AUKUS was built on.

Luke

Worth saying this is an opinion piece. The characterisation of the report is the author's reading, not a neutral audit.

Mark

Does he reject the report's central finding?

Mimi

Not entirely. He agrees US rotational bases could make Australia a target and that the risk outweighs the benefit.

Mark

So where does he part ways?

Mimi

He says Australia remains at risk from China even without those bases, and that Chinese ambitions don't disappear if AUKUS is cancelled.

Luke

That claim is argued, not demonstrated here. The piece cites China's military modernisation but gives no figures.

Mark

What's his alternative?

Mimi

A defence force lethal enough that China can never coerce Australia, plus scepticism toward both superpowers.

Luke

And his claim that AUKUS is slow, costly and uncertain is also his assessment. The piece offers no costs or timelines, so that's something to check elsewhere.

  • A public inquiry warns that AUKUS could drag Australia into a war with China, and its findings are already rippling through the national debate.
  • Critics say the report interrogates American motives sharply while letting the government's assertions about China's threat pass largely unchallenged.
  • The commentator argues that the logic behind AUKUS, that without American power only Chinese power remains, is a false choice that the inquiry barely touches.
  • Australia is urged to pursue a lethal, independent defence force and to view both a fading United States and a rising China with equal wariness.

In the autumn of this year, a public inquiry into AUKUS reached a sober conclusion: the pact, built on claims about China that have rarely been stated in full, may pull Australia toward a war it should fear above all else. Yet a commentator at the Lowy Institute sees in the report a mirror that reflects only half the picture, polishing its scrutiny of Washington while leaving Beijing's ambitions largely unexamined. His reading recalls an older human question, whether a nation's safety lies in borrowed power or in its own hands, and his answer is that a country should doubt every great power that looms over its region.

A report released this month by the AUKUS Public Inquiry, an initiative of the Australian Peace and Security Forum and backed by unions and community groups, concludes that the submarine pact raises the risk of Australia being drawn into war with China. It says the government's case rests on assertions about China that have never been properly spelled out, and it calls such a war the worst possible outcome for the country.

A Lowy Institute commentary agrees the government has been evasive, but argues the inquiry makes the same omission. AUKUS was born in 2021 on the belief that American power in Asia was needed to keep Beijing from becoming the region's dominant force, and that without it Australia would be forced to accommodate China on Beijing's terms. The report, the commentator says, mentions China's global weight, its activity in the South China Sea, and its role as Australia's largest trading partner, but then moves on quickly and never tests that founding fear.

The commentator makes one exception to his criticism. He accepts that Australian soil hosting American forces could make the country a target, and he agrees that risk outweighs the benefit. Still, he insists China's military modernisation poses danger regardless of those bases, and that the inquiry wrongly suggests Beijing's ambitions would disappear if AUKUS were cancelled.

His deeper point is that the real danger is coercion rather than invasion, the quiet compliance a fully dominant China could extract. He rejects the idea that Australia must choose between American and Chinese power. A lethal, independent defence force could make coercion fail, and AUKUS, being slow and costly, may stand in its way. His verdict is that the inquiry aims nearly all its doubt at Washington and very little at Beijing.

A report released this month by the AUKUS Public Inquiry carries a finding that is blunt about where it stands. Because AUKUS rests on assertions that China is a strategic threat to Australia, it says, the pact raises the likelihood of Australia being drawn into a war with China, which it calls the worst possible outcome for the country's future. The inquiry is an initiative of the Australian Peace and Security Forum and is backed by trade unions and community groups.

A commentary published by the Lowy Institute's Interpreter argues that the report is both right and incomplete. Its author credits the inquiry with exposing how successive Australian governments have refused to spell out those assertions about the China threat. Then comes the criticism: the report fails to spell them out either.

The commentary reminds readers why AUKUS exists. It was created in 2021 on the premise that Australia needed nuclear-powered submarines to reinforce American power in the region. The Morrison government and its advisers reasoned that without that power, Australia and every other Asian nation would be at Beijing's mercy. They would have to accommodate an ascendant China as the region's new hegemon. If the United States was not in charge in Asia, China would be, and Australia would be forced to seek peace on terms favourable to Beijing.

According to the author, this core logic is barely touched in the inquiry's report. Where the report does acknowledge China's growing power, it moves on quickly. It calls China a global superpower and the leading power in Asia, notes its activity in the South China Sea and its expanding sphere of influence in Southeast Asia and the Pacific, and describes China as Australia's largest trading partner and central to future prosperity. It then says AUKUS threatens that coexistence by contributing to the attempted containment of China, and that the decision was based on unsubstantiated threats from China and on US policy to contain and contest it.

The report also draws heavily on submissions that play down China's military threat. It makes one exception: the possibility that China might strike American bases on Australian soil. Without those bases, the argument goes, China has no quarrel with Australia and is vanishingly unlikely to attack. The commentator says he has himself warned that the new US rotational presence, which he describes as bases in all but name, could make Australia a target, and he agrees the risk outweighs the security benefit. But he insists Australia would still face risk from China's military even without those facilities. In his view the report also barely registers the scale and sophistication of China's military modernisation, and wrongly implies that Beijing's regional ambitions would vanish if AUKUS were cancelled or US forces left.

The real danger, he argues, is not invasion. A Beijing that was utterly dominant in the region would not need to invade, because Australian compliance could be obtained without force. That coercive power, which comes only from unchallenged strategic dominance, is the fear that inspired AUKUS: without American power, there is only Chinese power.

His answer is that this dichotomy is false, for two reasons. First, China is not fated to become the hegemon even without American power; Australia and its partners have agency, and one use of it would be to build a defence force so lethal and effective that China could never coerce it. He argues AUKUS makes that harder because it is expensive, slow and uncertain to deliver. Second, AUKUS will not cement American power in Asia. For Washington, he says, it is simply a favourable arms deal that does not oblige the US to defend a regional position that has been weakening for a generation, because it is unwilling to risk war with China.

He points to the dual scepticism he set out in his ABC Boyer Lecture: one superpower is declining as a regional force while the other rises, and Canberra should be wary of both. His verdict on the inquiry is that it directs nearly all its doubt at Washington and saves almost none for Beijing.

The report directs almost all its scepticism towards the United States and reserves little for China.
— Lowy Institute commentary author
AUKUS, premised on assertions that China is a strategic threat, increases the likelihood of war with China.
— AUKUS Public Inquiry report finding
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei Lowy Institute ↗
Kontakt FAQ