Some devices arrive carrying a promise that they will feel like the thing they resemble, and the ROG Xbox Ally X asks a reviewer to test that promise against the long memory of a childhood spent with handheld games. Wccftech's reviewer, who once buried his face in a Game Boy Advance SP and has never owned a PC handheld, spent three weeks with the device and found it impressive in the way that old wonder often is, while remaining unconvinced that a $999 machine should be bought lightly. It is, at heart, a Windows PC wearing an Xbox face, and its strengths and frustrations both trace back to tha
ASUS ROG Xbox Ally X Review: A Impressive Handheld That Still Isn't Quite an Xbox
A controller with a screen slapped in the middle
Mark
The headline asks whether this is an Xbox. What does the reviewer say?
Mimi
He says no. It runs Windows 11 with an Xbox interface layered on top, so it feels console-like, but it isn't a console.
Mark
What gave him that conclusion in practice?
Mimi
The library. Steam, Epic and GOG games are all there, but his full Xbox library isn't, including original Xbox and 360 games that run on his Series X.
Luke
Worth noting the source text cuts off mid-sentence there, so we don't have his full explanation of what's missing.
Mark
Fair. What about performance?
Mimi
Mixed. Red Dead Redemption 2 held 40 FPS at Ultra in 17W mode, and Forza Horizon 5 stayed at 60. But consistency was a problem across most titles, and he wouldn't recommend DOOM: The Dark Ages.
Luke
Those are one reviewer's informal numbers from internal benchmarks. He says himself he's no Digital Foundry, so treat them as indicative.
Mark
And the crashes?
Mimi
Elden Ring crashed repeatedly and Dying Light: The Beast once. He says that isn't necessarily the hardware's fault.
Luke
Right, and he doesn't establish the cause. It could be software, drivers or the pre-release unit he had to update by hand.
Mark
So who should buy it?
Mimi
He can't name that person, and at $999 USD he advises caution.
Il Polso
- A $999 price tag collides with a reviewer who admits he cannot justify buying any PC handheld, and every feature has to earn its place against that resistance.
- The device looks like a controller with a screen stuck in the middle, and five cramped top-corner buttons keep triggering the wrong menu, so the everyday controls fight the user.
- Frame rates swing between 30 and 60 across titles, and Doom: The Dark Ages is too unsteady to recommend, leaving performance on a knife's edge.
- Elden Ring crashes almost constantly, pulling stability into the conversation even though the reviewer suggests the fault may not lie with the hardware.
- Battery life holds up well in Performance mode, so the device lands as a strong portable for some buyers while the reviewer still urges caution to anyone weighing it against the Steam Deck and cheaper ROG Ally models.
Some devices arrive carrying a promise that they will feel like the thing they resemble, and the ROG Xbox Ally X asks a reviewer to test that promise against the long memory of a childhood spent with handheld games. Wccftech's reviewer, who once buried his face in a Game Boy Advance SP and has never owned a PC handheld, spent three weeks with the device and found it impressive in the way that old wonder often is, while remaining unconvinced that a $999 machine should be bought lightly. It is, at heart, a Windows PC wearing an Xbox face, and its strengths and frustrations both trace back to that honest identity. The reviewer's conclusion, that it is not a console, reads less like a verdict than a reminder that the category has grown faster than the prices people are willing to pay for it.
The reviewer has loved handhelds since childhood, with photos of him lost in a Game Boy Advance SP, one of them on a beach. So he was surprised to feel put off when he first held the ASUS ROG Xbox Ally X earlier this month. After three weeks with a review unit, his verdict is mixed: the device is impressive, worthwhile for some, but hard to recommend at $999 USD to anyone who has to think carefully about money.
He owns no PC handheld and cannot justify a Steam Deck or ROG Ally on top of the consoles and PC he already has. Still, playing games he never expected to see on a handheld a few years ago won him over. The grips make the 715-gram body comfortable through long sessions, even if the device looks a little like a controller with a screen in the middle. Setup was rougher than it should be, since his unit lacked day-one updates, and buyers should not face that.
The Xbox interface makes the device feel console-like, and the buttons mostly delight, though the top-corner controls and a misplaced Library button sent him into the wrong menu more than once. Battery life is decent, and the 17W Performance mode handles nearly everything, so he rarely needed Turbo. Frame rates were the recurring trouble: Forza Horizon 5 held a smooth 60, but Doom: The Dark Ages was not worth playing on it. Stability was weaker still, with Elden Ring crashing repeatedly, though he notes that such crashes are not always the hardware's fault.
His answer to the title's question is no. It is a Windows 11 PC handheld with an Xbox face, and it is excellent for carrying Steam, Epic and GOG libraries, while his full Xbox library stays behind. Whether it is worth $999 depends on how a buyer weighs it against the alternatives.
The reviewer's history with handhelds goes back to childhood: there are photos of him with his face buried in a Game Boy Advance SP, one of them taken on a beach. On paper, that makes him an ideal buyer for the ASUS ROG Xbox Ally X. So he was surprised to find he was put off by the device when he first held it earlier this month. Wccftech's review, published October 15, 2025, comes after three weeks with a unit ASUS sent over for the purpose.
He is upfront that he owns no PC handheld. He has a laptop, a desktop, a PS5, an Xbox Series X and a Switch, and he can't justify spending on a Steam Deck, an ROG Ally or anything similar. The Xbox Ally X costs $999 USD, or $1299 CAD, and is one of the most expensive devices of its kind. Even so, time with it showed him the appeal. Playing games on it that he never expected to see in a handheld a few years ago is, in his words, simply impressive. His verdict is mixed: a worthwhile device for some, though he would still caution anyone with that much money to spend against buying one.
The first objection was looks. He wouldn't call it ugly, but the controller-style grips on either side give it the air of a controller with a screen stuck in the middle. The grips do make the 715g device comfortable over long sessions. The box holds a 65Wh charger, which pushes the device into a 35W Turbo mode when plugged in, plus manuals, a warranty card and a small cardboard stand. His unit lacked the day-one updates, so setup meant several pre-release updates and a guide. Buyers shouldn't face that.
The device boots into the Xbox PC app, with a new interface refresh that is also coming to the original ROG Ally and Ally X as an update. A fingerprint reader on the power button makes waking it simple. The rear buttons click satisfyingly, the sticks sit comfortably, the triggers pull smoothly, and the D-pad handled Celeste well, which is the game he played most. The ABXY buttons feel a bit sticky. His main complaint is five buttons on the top corners, two on one side and three on the other. The Armoury Crate button and the Xbox button open the same side menu, and the Library button above the Menu button on the right led him into an Armoury Crate menu by accident more than once. ASUS also sent a 2-in-1 hard-shell case with a velcro pouch for the charger, though the retaining strap makes it slow to remove the handheld.
On hardware, the Xbox Ally X tops the ROG Ally line with a Ryzen AI Z2 Extreme processor. It adds no cores but improves battery efficiency. Compared with the ROG Ally X, it also has faster memory, improved USB ports and the new grip shape, and that is about where the upgrades end, apart from the Xbox button. The screen is a 7-inch, 1920x1080 IPS panel at 500 nits and 120Hz. ASUS's Whitson Gordon and Sashca Krohn told him battery life drove the choice of IPS over OLED. He doesn't mind, since OLED would raise a price he already finds hard to recommend.
Battery results are decent. One hour of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Turbo left the battery at 50%. He found he rarely needed Turbo, because the 17W Performance mode handled nearly everything he tried and stretched play time considerably.
His benchmarks covered Forza Horizon 5, DOOM: The Dark Ages, Red Dead Redemption 2, Horizon Zero Dawn and Shadow of the Tomb Raider. Most could pass 30 FPS or even 60, but holding a steady frame rate was a recurring problem. Forza Horizon 5 alone stayed at a smooth 60. Built-in VRR helps, but he would not recommend playing DOOM: The Dark Ages on it. Red Dead Redemption 2 held 40 FPS in 17W mode at Ultra settings and fell to 30 in Silent mode. Shadow of the Tomb Raider reached about 40 FPS in both Turbo modes and in Performance mode, and 30 in Silent. Horizon Zero Dawn ran near 40 FPS in Performance mode and 30 in Silent, and on Favour Performance settings it reached nearly 50 FPS at 17W.
Stability was a weaker point. Elden Ring crashed almost every time: after using the volume buttons, twice when navigating menus with LB and RB, and once mid-gameplay for no clear reason. Dying Light: The Beast crashed once, on the way from the Town Hall safe zone into Old Town. He notes such crashes aren't necessarily the hardware's fault.
His answer to the title's question is no. It is a Windows 11 PC handheld with an Xbox interface that makes it act more like a console, but it isn't one. Steam, Epic and GOG libraries are available on the go, which he loves. His full Xbox library is not, and the original Xbox and Xbox 360 games that play on his Series X don't appear under his owned games. For buyers, the question is whether $999 is justified next to the Steam Deck and existing ROG Ally models.
Citazioni salienti
It's a PC handheld that runs Windows 11 and a special Xbox UI, but it's not a console.— Wccftech reviewer
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su Wccftech ↗
Media & Entertainment