Gathered in Manila, the ASEAN nations and China came close enough to a South China Sea code of conduct to feel its shape, yet a final text still eludes them after more than two decades of talks, with the question of whether it should bind the parties standing unresolved at its edge. The same meeting carried the older, heavier weight of Myanmar, where a peace plan agreed in 2021 has not quieted the war, and the bloc kept its leader barred from the summits in response. In both cases the region has chosen patience over rupture, passing unfinished work to Singapore as the next chair. What remains
ASEAN and China Fall Short on South China Sea Code as Myanmar Ban Is Extended
Eighty percent agreed, and the last fifth is the part that matters
Gathered in Manila, the ASEAN nations and China came close enough to a South China Sea code of conduct to feel its shape, yet a final text still eludes them after more than two decades of talks, with the question of whether it should bind the parties standing unresolved at its edge. The same meeting carried the older, heavier weight of Myanmar, where a peace plan agreed in 2021 has not quieted the war, and the bloc kept its leader barred from the summits in response. In both cases the region has chosen patience over rupture, passing unfinished work to Singapore as the next chair. What remains is the old human question of whether shared rules can hold when the sea and the country are both contested.
On Sunday in Manila, Philippine Foreign Minister Theresa Lazaro admitted what negotiators had failed to say for over twenty years: there is still no finished code of conduct for the South China Sea. The sides have tentatively agreed on about 80 percent of the draft, but the rest is the hard part. Whether the code would be legally binding remains open, and the ASEAN states and China still see the matter differently. The Philippines had pledged to finish by the end of 2026, and that deadline has passed. Lazaro says she still hopes Singapore, which takes the chair next year, can complete it.
The stakes are practical. China claims most of the sea, overlapping the exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam. A working code would keep tensions from escalating and steer encounters between vessels. Southeast Asian states want it grounded in international law, which they say China has ignored. Beijing calls its conduct lawful and professional and rejects the 2016 arbitration ruling against its sweeping claims. The sharpest friction is with Manila, where Chinese ships have been accused of dangerous manoeuvres, water cannon use and disrupted resupply missions.
Alongside this, ASEAN extended its ban on Myanmar's leader attending summits, citing non-compliance with the 2021 Five-Point Consensus. Myanmar's representatives can only be lower-level diplomats, and the chair that Myanmar was due to hold passed to the Philippines because of the civil strife. The leaders voiced deep concern, urged an end to attacks on civilians, and criticised both the military and armed groups. Lazaro, the bloc's envoy to Myanmar, cited continuing bombings and displacement and said ASEAN would let authorities tackle the problem step by step while monitoring the results.
The ban sits uneasily beside reality. Min Aung Hlaing, the former military chief, is now president after elections widely seen as rigged, and he has made official visits to several member states without discouragement. Singapore inherits both files: an unfinished code and a peace plan that has not yet brought peace.
On Sunday, at the ASEAN summit in Manila, Philippine Foreign Minister Theresa Lazaro told reporters what negotiators had been unable to say for more than twenty years: there is still no finished code of conduct for the South China Sea. "There is no conclusion yet," she said, even though the sides have tentatively agreed on about 80 percent of the draft.
The remaining fifth is the hard part. Lazaro said several key issues are unresolved, among them whether the code would be legally binding. She also acknowledged that the ASEAN countries and China see things differently. The Philippines holds the rotating chair of the 11-nation association this year and had pledged to speed up the talks and reach a deal by the end of 2026. That did not happen. Lazaro said she still hopes the code can be completed under Singapore, which takes over as chair next year.
The stakes are practical. China claims most of the South China Sea, and that claim collides with the exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam. A functional code is meant to keep tensions from escalating and to manage encounters between vessels at sea. Southeast Asian nations want it to reflect international law, which some of them accuse China of ignoring. Beijing insists its actions have been lawful and professional. In 2016, an international arbitration tribunal ruled that China's sweeping claims have no basis in international law, a ruling Beijing rejects.
The friction is sharpest between China and the Philippines, which have faced off in a series of maritime confrontations in recent years. Manila accuses Chinese ships of repeated aggressive actions inside its exclusive economic zone, including dangerous manoeuvres, water cannon fire and disruption of resupply missions. China, for its part, accuses the Philippines of intruding on its territory. Tensions rose after President Ferdinand Marcos Jr took office in 2022, and months of harsh words over the sea preceded this weekend's meetings.
Separately, ASEAN extended its ban on Myanmar's leader attending the bloc's annual summits, saying the country has failed to comply with a 2021 peace plan. Under the ban, Myanmar can be represented only by lower-level career diplomats, including at the Manila summit. Myanmar was due to hold the rotating chair this year, but because of the civil strife the role passed to the Philippines.
The decision followed a review of the Five-Point Consensus, which ASEAN approved in April 2021 to ease the violence that followed the military's seizure of power from Aung San Suu Kyi's elected government in February of that year. The coup set off pro-democracy protests that were brutally put down, then armed resistance and a civil war that has spread over much of the country. In Manila, leaders voiced "deep concern" over insufficient progress and urged all parties to "stop targeted attacks against civilians and civilian infrastructure." They also criticised both the military and armed groups for continuing to attack civilians.
Lazaro, who is also ASEAN's special envoy to Myanmar, pointed to "still certain bombings and displacement of Myanmar people." She said the bloc would give Myanmar's authorities room to tackle the problem step by step, and that ASEAN would monitor the result.
The ban sits alongside a more complicated reality. Min Aung Hlaing, the former military chief, became president after elections in December and January that were widely seen as rigged, and he has since made official visits to several ASEAN member states. ASEAN has not discouraged those trips, though its leaders stress that the peace plan remains "the main reference for addressing the political crisis in Myanmar." Next year's chair, Singapore, inherits both files: an unfinished code and a stalled peace plan.
Citations marquantes
There is no conclusion yet.— Theresa Lazaro, Philippine foreign minister
ASEAN leaders expressed deep concern over insufficient progress on Myanmar's peace plan and urged an end to targeted attacks on civilians.— ASEAN leaders' statement, Manila