In Saxony-Anhalt, a former East German state where economic unease and demographic shifts have long simmered, the far-right Alternative for Germany party has claimed roughly 44 percent of the regional vote — more than doubling its share from five years prior. Yet electoral strength and governing power remain two separate things: every major German party has refused, in advance, to enter coalition with the AfD, erecting a deliberate barrier between popular will and political authority. The result is a tension as old as democracy itself — the question of what a society owes to a movement it fear
AfD surges in German regional election but faces coalition isolation
44 percent of the vote, yet locked out of power entirely
Mark
So the AfD got 44 percent in Saxony-Anhalt. That's a huge number. Why aren't they forming the government?
Mimi
Because every other party in Germany has said they won't work with them. It's a deliberate choice to keep them out, even though they won the most votes.
Mark
But isn't that undemocratic? If they got 44 percent, shouldn't they have a say in who governs?
Mimi
That's the tension. Technically, yes—but the other parties see the AfD as incompatible with how German democracy is supposed to work, especially given the country's history.
Luke
We should be clear about what we actually know here. The AfD got 44 percent—that's confirmed. The other parties have said they won't work with them—that's also confirmed. But whether a coalition without them is even mathematically possible, we don't know yet. That depends on the full election results.
Mark
So it's possible the other parties might have to work with them anyway?
Luke
It's possible, yes. If the numbers don't add up any other way, the pressure to reconsider becomes real.
Mimi
And that's what makes this moment so significant. It's not just about one election. It's about whether Germany can sustain a system where the strongest party is locked out of power.
Mark
What happens if they can't form a government?
Mimi
Then you're in uncharted territory. New elections, maybe. Or eventually, someone has to negotiate with the AfD.
Luke
And we don't know how voters will react to that either. Will they punish the other parties for refusing to govern with the strongest party? Or will they support the cordon sanitaire?
Le Pouls
- The AfD's 44 percent result in Saxony-Anhalt is not a ripple but a wave — the party has more than doubled its support in five years, signaling deep and accelerating roots in eastern Germany.
- Every major established party — the CDU, SPD, Greens, and FDP — preemptively declared they would not govern alongside the AfD, transforming the election into a collision between ballot-box power and institutional refusal.
- The arithmetic is unforgiving: if the remaining parties cannot assemble a stable majority among themselves, the cordon sanitaire will face its first real structural test.
- The AfD, locked out of power despite its dominance, gains a potent narrative — that the system is designed to silence its voters — which may fuel further growth rather than contain it.
- Saxony-Anhalt has become a national referendum on whether democratic norms can hold against a far-right surge, with the coming coalition negotiations watched as a bellwether for all of Germany.
In Saxony-Anhalt, a former East German state where economic unease and demographic shifts have long simmered, the far-right Alternative for Germany party has claimed roughly 44 percent of the regional vote — more than doubling its share from five years prior. Yet electoral strength and governing power remain two separate things: every major German party has refused, in advance, to enter coalition with the AfD, erecting a deliberate barrier between popular will and political authority. The result is a tension as old as democracy itself — the question of what a society owes to a movement it fears, and what it risks by refusing to answer.
The Alternative for Germany has delivered a striking result in Saxony-Anhalt, capturing roughly 44 percent of the regional vote — more than twice what it managed in 2021. The surge reflects years of patient organizing across eastern Germany, where economic anxiety and demographic change have made the AfD's messaging resonate at levels rarely seen in the west.
Yet the result tells only half the story. Germany's established parties — the Christian Democrats, Social Democrats, Greens, and Free Democrats — had already ruled out any coalition with the AfD before a single vote was counted. This is not a negotiating posture but a deliberate democratic firewall, a judgment that the far-right party is fundamentally incompatible with the postwar political order.
The tension between those two realities — dominant electoral performance on one side, categorical exclusion on the other — is without precedent at the German state level. If the remaining parties can assemble a workable majority among themselves, the cordon holds. If they cannot, the pressure to reconsider will be immense.
The AfD, meanwhile, can claim a powerful grievance: that nearly half the electorate voted for it and was still shut out of power. That narrative, whether fair or not, has historically fed the very movements democratic establishments seek to contain. How Saxony-Anhalt resolves its coalition arithmetic in the weeks ahead may well determine how Germany confronts the far-right question for years to come.
The Alternative for Germany, a far-right party that has spent years building support in the country's eastern regions, has achieved a striking result in Saxony-Anhalt: roughly 44 percent of the vote in a regional election, a figure that more than doubles what the party managed five years earlier. The projection marks a significant moment in German politics—a demonstration of how substantially the AfD's base has grown and how deeply it has penetrated electoral politics in parts of the country where economic anxiety and demographic change have created fertile ground for its messaging.
Yet the election result, dramatic as it is, tells only half the story. The other half is one of isolation. Germany's established political parties—the Christian Democrats, the Social Democrats, the Greens, and the Free Democrats—have all made clear, well before the votes were counted, that they will not form coalitions with the AfD. This preemptive refusal is not a casual negotiating position. It reflects a deliberate strategy to contain the far-right party's influence despite its electoral strength, a kind of democratic cordon sanitaire that treats the AfD as fundamentally incompatible with the country's postwar political order.
The tension between these two facts—massive electoral support on one side, categorical rejection by all potential governing partners on the other—creates an unprecedented puzzle for German politics. The AfD has never before held power at the state level. Whether it can translate its 44 percent into actual government authority now depends entirely on whether the other parties can construct a viable coalition without it, or whether the arithmetic of the election makes that impossible.
Saxony-Anhalt, a state in the former East Germany, has become a testing ground for questions that extend far beyond regional politics. The AfD's surge there reflects patterns visible across eastern Germany, where the party has built a substantial organizational presence and where voters have shown themselves willing to support it at levels that would be unthinkable in much of the west. The doubling of support in five years suggests momentum, not a plateau.
But the other parties' refusal to work with the AfD, even when it might be arithmetically convenient to do so, signals something equally important: a consensus that certain lines should not be crossed, that electoral success does not automatically confer the right to govern. This stance carries its own risks. If the AfD continues to grow electorally while remaining locked out of power, it can claim victimhood and argue that the system is rigged against it. If the other parties cannot form a stable government without it, the pressure to reconsider that refusal will mount.
What happens next in Saxony-Anhalt will likely shape how German politics handles the AfD question going forward. Can the other parties construct a workable coalition? Will voters punish them for refusing to include the strongest party in the state? And perhaps most fundamentally: how long can a democratic system sustain a situation in which a party with 44 percent of the vote is excluded from power? These questions have no easy answers, and the coming weeks will test whether Germany's political establishment can maintain its united front against the far-right's advance.
Citations marquantes
Other major parties have ruled out working with the AfD— German political establishment
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur Al Jazeera ↗
Politics & Governance