A Year In, Mark Carney Heads to Asia as a Political Star Courting Middle Powers Beyond Washington

A dense web of connections so we're not told what to do by some hegemon
Carney described his strategy of building ties beyond the U.S. at a news conference in Manila.
Mark

Why does a Dublin stop matter in a story about Asia?

Mimi

It shows where the weight sits right now. Carney is seeking associate membership in the EU, and he added Dublin to a trip already planned for Asia.

Luke

But the experts quoted say Asia is the bigger economic opportunity. So is Europe the priority or not?

Mimi

Both claims hold. Europe is the political priority and is far more popular at home, 58 percent versus 14 percent for China. Asia is where the larger market potential is.

Mark

What has changed since last year at these summits?

Mimi

He went from a curiosity to a marquee attraction, after the Davos speech and Trump's energy security threats.

Luke

That's the reporting's explanation, though. We can't say for certain what drove the new attention.

Mark

What did he actually secure?

Mimi

Completed broad negotiations on a deal with the Philippines, and talks are underway with all 11 ASEAN countries. Those talks aren't finished.

Luke

And China? In January he predicted substantial Chinese auto investment within three years. Now he's hedging, tying it to where the U.S. relationship settles. Nothing is confirmed there.

Mark

Where does he draw the line with Putin?

Mimi

He'll stand in the photo out of respect for the host, but Russian and Belarusian teams are barred from the junior hockey championship.

  • Trade with the United States has become unpredictable, and Ottawa is scrambling to build alternatives before the ground shifts further.
  • Carney's Asia tour has drawn applause and deal announcements, yet Canadian opinion is cool toward China, which complicates any pivot toward Beijing.
  • A Philippine trade deal is largely negotiated, and a wider accord with all 11 ASEAN countries is in active talks.
  • At Shenzhen, Carney faces Xi, Putin and Trump in one room, and every handshake and photograph carries diplomatic weight.
  • Whether Chinese automakers invest in Canada, and how the U.S. relationship settles, will determine whether this diversification becomes durable.

Mark Carney, Canada's prime minister, is moving his country's trade and politics away from a long dependence on the United States, and the journey now runs through Dublin, Manila, Phnom Penh and Shenzhen rather than only through Washington. Canada has sought associate membership in the European Union and completed broad talks with the Philippines, while his stance toward China remains guarded, shaped by a recent history of hostage-taking and interference and by a public that wants Europe far more than Beijing. What is unfolding is less a clean break than a patient effort by a middle power to widen its web of partners so that no single hegemon, or single platform, can dictate its course.

Mark Carney added a stop in Dublin to his travel schedule last week, joining European leaders before continuing to a planned trip to Asia. The detour signaled priorities. Last month he announced that Canada is seeking to become the first associate member of the European Union, part of a push to loosen the economy and politics from dependence on the United States. Experts argue the larger economic prize may lie in Asia, and that a coalition of middle powers requires it.

A year ago, Carney was something of a curiosity at Southeast Asian and Pacific gatherings. A January speech at Davos, combined with President Trump's expanding trade war and new energy security threats, made him and his energy-rich country a marquee attraction. In Manila, Carney announced that broad negotiations for a trade deal with the Philippines were complete, and talks with all 11 ASEAN countries are underway. He called his strategy deliberate, aimed at a dense web of connections so Canada is not told what to do by any hegemon or hyperscaler. At a stop in Cambodia, he drew more applause than anyone else at a francophone gathering.

The APEC meeting in Shenzhen will be harder. Xi will host Putin and Trump, and Carney says he will join the group photo with Putin out of respect for the host, but no further. Canada will keep Russian and Belarusian teams out of the junior hockey championship and stands firmly with Ukraine.

China remains the largest potential market, but relations collapsed after Chinese arrests of two Canadians and an inquiry into Chinese political interference. Since Carney restored ties, Canadian goodwill toward China has grown, yet only 14 percent favor closer trade with it, while 58 percent want more trade with Europe. Carney once predicted substantial Chinese auto investment within three years; he now speaks more cautiously, tying the outcome to the future of the American trade relationship. That answer, and what emerges from the Xi meeting, will reveal how far the pivot can go.

Mark Carney added a stop in Dublin to his travel schedule last week, joining a gathering of European leaders before he set out on a trip to Asia that had been planned in advance. The detour said something about priorities. Last month the Canadian prime minister announced that Canada is formally seeking to become the first "associate member" of the European Union, part of his effort to move Canada's economy and politics away from dependence on the United States. Experts, though, say the larger economic prize may lie in Asia.

Kazuto Suzuki, a professor at the University of Tokyo's graduate school of public policy, put it this way: Carney's focus on Europe may give the impression that he is not looking toward Asia, but if Canada wants to avoid reliance on the American market and build a coalition of middle powers, cooperation with Asia is essential.

The reception has changed in a year. At last year's meetings of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, Carney was something of a curiosity. Then came his January speech at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, and President Trump's decision to add energy security threats to his trade war with the world. Together they made Carney, and his energy-rich country, a marquee attraction at both gatherings.

The trip has already produced results. In Manila, before the ASEAN meetings opened, Carney announced that Canada had completed the broad negotiations for a trade deal with the Philippines. Talks are also underway on a wider arrangement with all 11 ASEAN countries. This week, ahead of the APEC meeting in Shenzhen, China, he will hold his second formal meeting of the year with Xi Jinping. On Saturday he said he would press his call for middle powers to unite at both summits, and would pitch Canada as a dependable supplier of oil and gas as the United States grows less predictable. After meeting Philippine President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr., he was blunt that this is strategy, "100 percent," aimed at building a dense web of connections so Canada is not told what to do by "some hegemon or a hyperscaler." Many other countries, he added, are pursuing similar strategies to varying degrees, which is one reason he sees so much progress.

Between the two summits, Carney stopped briefly in Cambodia, host of a meeting of the International Organization of Francophonie, which promotes French language and culture. When leaders were introduced, he drew noticeably more applause than anyone else.

APEC will be harder. Xi will host both Vladimir Putin and Trump, and Putin's presence, after he skipped last year's APEC meeting in South Korea, contrasts sharply with the European Political Community summit in Dublin, where Carney and his counterparts reaffirmed unqualified support for Ukraine alongside President Volodymyr Zelensky. Carney said he will join the group photograph with Putin "out of respect for the host," but that seems to be his limit. He repeated that Canada will bar Russian and Belarusian teams from the Men's World Junior Hockey Championship at the end of the year, and said Canada's stand for Ukraine, democracy, territorial integrity and the rule of law puts it on the other side of Putin's Russia.

China is the biggest potential market for replacing American trade, but the relationship was already sulfurous before Carney, a former governor of the Bank of Canada and the Bank of England, entered politics last year. It collapsed after China arrested two Canadians, widely seen in Canada as hostage-taking in retaliation for Canada's arrest of a Chinese telecommunications executive on a U.S. extradition request. An inquiry also concluded that China had tried to interfere in Canadian politics. Polls suggest Canadians' good will toward China has grown since Carney restored relations, while views of the United States under Trump, who started a trade war and keeps suggesting Canada should be the 51st state, have moved the other way.

Still, there are limits. An Angus Reid Institute poll found only 14 percent of Canadians favor closer trade ties with China, versus 58 percent who want more trade with Europe. In January, after meeting Xi, Carney predicted Chinese automakers would make substantial investments in Canada within three years. On Saturday he was more cautious, saying the government wants a competitive auto sector with good union jobs while also giving Canadians access to affordable electric cars, and that the path depends in part on where the U.S. trading relationship settles. That answer, and whatever comes out of the Xi meeting, are the things to watch.

It's part of our strategy, absolutely, 100 percent.
— Mark Carney, news conference in Manila
If Canada is to avoid dependence on the U.S. market and form a coalition of middle powers, cooperation with Asia is essential.
— Kazuto Suzuki, University of Tokyo
Envie de l'histoire complète ? Lire l'original sur The New York Times ↗
Nous contacter FAQ