A Small Three-Country Oil-Sharing Pilot Offers ASEAN a Model for Faster, Incentive-Driven Cooperation

The key, as always, is ensuring that incentives are aligned.
The analysis closes on what the three-country oil pilot suggests for ASEAN's wider energy security efforts.
Mark

Why does a letter of intent between three countries deserve attention?

Mimi

Because six months ago ASEAN leaders could only agree to study a regional stockpile. Now there is a concrete mechanism, a ticket system, with named companies on the Philippine, Indonesian and Thai sides.

Mark

What is a ticket, in plain terms?

Mimi

The seller reserves oil for the buyer and charges a fee. The buyer keeps access during a crisis. Europe and Japan with New Zealand already do it.

Luke

Let's be careful, though. These are letters of intent, not binding contracts. Nothing in the reporting says volumes, fees or delivery terms have been fixed.

Mimi

Fair. The report on stockpiling says governments usually agree a volume first and then companies sign. We don't know where that stands here.

Mark

Why only three countries?

Mimi

Analysts say the Philippines was hit hard and wanted to act, while Thailand and Indonesia had capacity to offer.

Luke

That's the analysts' explanation, relayed through The Straits Times. It's plausible, but it isn't a stated reason from the governments.

Mark

And the bigger claim, that this is a model for ASEAN?

Mimi

Joel Ng ties it to the old "ASEAN minus X" idea. Laos and Timor-Leste are reportedly considering joining, and Brunei has private-sector talks.

Luke

Note those are a Nikkei report and one unnamed observer. Nobody has confirmed accession, and APSA's lack of a physical stockpile hasn't changed yet.

  • Fuel prices and supply fears from a Middle East conflict pushed the Philippines to seek an emergency oil lifeline fast.
  • ASEAN's May promise to merely study a regional stockpile left the hard questions of location and cost unanswered.
  • Three countries are now quietly building a 'ticket' arrangement, reserving oil for a buyer in exchange for a fee.
  • Laos and Timor-Leste are reportedly weighing entry, while Brunei's private sector is already in talks.
  • The pilot is still at letter-of-intent stage, and its success will decide whether the updated ASEAN Petroleum Security Agreement gains real teeth.

In mid-November, on the sidelines of an ASEAN business summit, the Philippines' state oil company moved from talk to paper by signing letters of intent with partners in Indonesia and Thailand for a pilot that would let it draw on oil stored elsewhere in the region during an emergency. The step arrives after a fuel shock that rattled South-east Asia and exposed how little the grouping had built to protect itself, a gap that cooperation on paper has long failed to close. It is small, three countries and no binding stockpile yet, but it tests a familiar question in regional life: whether shared need and practical incentives can achieve what consensus alone has struggled to deliver.

On November 13, at the ASEAN Business and Investment Summit, the Philippines' state-owned oil company, PNOC Exploration, signed two letters of intent: one with an Indonesian company, one with a Thai company. The aim is a pilot that would let the Philippines draw on oil reserves held elsewhere in the region if an emergency strikes.

Half a year earlier, such a step seemed distant. A fuel crisis triggered by the Middle East conflict had left South-east Asia reeling. At the May summit, ASEAN leaders agreed only to study a regional oil stockpile, leaving open where it should sit and what it would cost. Those who know the grouping expected no quick answers; ASEAN moves by consensus, and its slowness is often criticised.

The pilot works on a "ticket" model: a seller holds back oil for a buyer for a fee, so the buyer keeps access even in a crisis. The Philippines was hit hardest, giving it urgency, while Thailand and Indonesia had the capacity to supply. Analysts see the three-country start not as division but as a practical route, the "ASEAN minus X" approach, in which some members move ahead and others may follow. A regional stockpile also costs less than national ones, since the receiving country needs no new infrastructure, a point that matters most for smaller states. Laos and Timor-Leste are reportedly considering joining, and Brunei's private sector is in discussion.

The pilot is still early, but it arrives as leaders push to ratify the updated ASEAN Petroleum Security Agreement, which critics say lacks a physical stockpile. Whether aligned incentives can fill that gap will be tested here.

On Nov 13, at the ASEAN Business and Investment Summit, the Philippines' state-owned oil company, PNOC Exploration Corporation, signed two separate letters of intent: one with a company in Indonesia, the other with a company in Thailand. The purpose is a pilot that would let the Philippines draw on oil reserves held elsewhere in the region if an emergency hits.

Six months earlier, the idea looked far less likely. South-east Asia was reeling from a fuel crisis set off by the Middle East conflict. At the May summit, ASEAN leaders agreed only to study the feasibility of a regional oil stockpile, and basic questions went unanswered: where the reserves should be sited, and at what cost. People familiar with how the grouping works did not expect those questions to be settled quickly. ASEAN runs on consensus and is often criticised for moving slowly.

The pilot uses a "ticket" system. A seller agrees to hold back a quantity of oil for a buyer in exchange for a fee, so the buyer keeps access to supply even in a crisis. The arrangement is already used in Europe and between Japan and New Zealand. According to a November report on oil stockpiling strategy from the Economic Research Institute for ASEAN and East Asia (ERIA), the two governments would usually agree on a stockpile volume first, and then their agencies, typically oil companies or related entities, would sign a contract. ERIA, which is Tokyo-backed and based in Jakarta, supplied much of the strategic advice behind the project. It and the Indonesian Business Council then brought stakeholders together, including a high-level business roundtable in Singapore in July 2026.

The pilot involves only three countries, which may prompt questions about an initiative meant to be regional. Analysts who spoke to The Straits Times said that does not signal disunity. The Philippines was hit particularly hard by the oil crisis, which gave it reason to move fast, while Thailand and Indonesia already had the capacity to offer.

Joel Ng, a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, described the approach as resembling the "ASEAN minus X" or "two plus X" formula, in which a smaller group of members proceeds while others decide whether to join. Malaysia proposed that formula more than two decades ago to speed up liberalisation of intra-ASEAN trade in services, but it never caught on outside economics. Jennifer Schuch-Page, managing principal at The Asia Group, said it is often easier to build an innovative framework with fewer countries and then add others that bring complementary strengths.

There is also a cost argument. A national stockpile may be preferable on security grounds, but a regional one is far cheaper because the receiving country does not need to build additional infrastructure. That matters most for smaller states. According to a Nikkei report, Laos and Timor-Leste are considering joining the three. An observer familiar with Brunei's oil and gas industry told The Straits Times that similar discussions are under way in the private sector there, and that commercial arrangements can move faster than state-directed ones.

The timing bears on the updated ASEAN Petroleum Security Agreement (APSA), which leaders are pushing to ratify fully at the ongoing summit. Critics have long questioned its usefulness because it has no physical regional stockpile and energy sharing under it is voluntary or commercial. The trilateral pilot, still at the letter-of-intent stage, is an early test of whether aligned incentives can supply what the agreement lacks.

The trilateral approach resembles the 'ASEAN minus X' or 'two plus X' formula, where a smaller group proceeds first while others get on board.
— Joel Ng, S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies
It is often easier to set up an innovative framework with fewer countries and later add others who offer additional complementarities.
— Jennifer Schuch-Page, The Asia Group
Fale Conosco FAQ