A Republican Party That's Learned Nothing: Why Defeating MAGA Is Only Half the Work

There is no path back to decency without defeating MAGA.
The columnist argues Republicans cannot revive their party without confronting Trump, even after the midterm rebuke.
Mark

The column says defeating MAGA is only half the work. What's the other half?

Mimi

Rebuilding a conservative party with actual principles. The writer argues that if Republicans collapse without that, voters unhappy with Democrats have nowhere decent to go.

Mark

He lists Miller, Jordan, Hegseth. Is that proof the party learned nothing?

Luke

It's his reading of those events. The appointments are facts; the conclusion that they show no reckoning is opinion. Some Republicans might say they're choosing fighters after a loss.

Mimi

Fair, but he's pointing at a pattern, and he backs the Jordan point with a Columbus Dispatch line about no bills he's led becoming law.

Mark

He also blames the immigration crackdown more than the Iran war for the losses.

Luke

That's an inference. He says Trump's approval was falling before the war and the Hispanic drop was "almost certainly" tied to immigration. Note the hedge. No polling is cited in the piece.

Mimi

Right, and that's the fight inside the GOP now: MAGA voices blame neocons and the war.

Mark

What would constitutional conservatism look like?

Mimi

Congress takes back tariffs and war powers, due process is protected, Ukraine gets help, and the founding's inclusiveness is honored.

Luke

Worth noting he admits many Democrats would agree. And the claim that a civil war is set up is a forecast, not something reported.

  • The midterm defeat, described as the largest rebuke to a party since 1974, has produced no visible reckoning inside the Republican ranks.
  • Stephen Miller's elevation to chief of staff and Jim Jordan's selection as House minority leader signal a doubling down rather than a retreat.
  • Fights over legal threats to investigators, impeachment protections for Pete Hegseth, and the Iran war have sharpened charges that constitutional guardrails are eroding.
  • The columnist urges Republicans to reclaim constitutional conservatism, restoring congressional powers over tariffs and war, and defending due process and free speech.
  • A Republican civil war looms, and the outcome will decide whether the party becomes a decent conservative force or stays locked in a volatile MAGA cycle.

In the weeks after a midterm rebuke that many regard as the sharpest any party has absorbed in half a century, the Republican Party has appeared to move in the same direction it was already traveling, elevating familiar figures and defending familiar tactics. The columnist reads this as a failure of memory more than a failure of strategy: a movement that has not yet asked what its defeat was trying to tell it. Against that backdrop, he offers an older vocabulary of conservatism, one rooted in the Constitution and the founding's inclusive promise, as a way out. Whether the party can recover that vocabulary, or whether its next chapter will be written by the same forces that produced the loss, is the question that hangs over the nation's politics.

The column opens with a blunt warning: beating MAGA at the polls is only half the work. The Republican Party, the writer argues, took the largest midterm rebuke any party has suffered since 1974 and has learned nothing from it. He points to the evidence. President Trump raised Stephen Miller to chief of staff, a man the writer holds largely responsible for a harsh immigration crackdown that may have cost the party Hispanic voters for a generation. House Republicans chose Jim Jordan as minority leader, a figure the columnist describes through a critic's words as a backroom brawler with little record of enacted legislation.

The list grows longer. The White House and Justice Department have threatened Democrats with legal consequences for investigating corruption, which the writer calls preposterous given the constitutional power of inquiry. House Republicans shielded Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth from impeachment, though the columnist says he helped carry out an unconstitutional war against Iran. Critics of MAGA, he notes, could simply enjoy the spectacle and wait for 2028, and he suspects that is what will happen. But he rejects that comfort. American politics will remain unstable until the party undergoes a real moral and ideological renewal.

His answer is a return to constitutional conservatism, defined in George Will's terms as preserving the founding's principles and institutions. That means giving tariff authority back to Congress, restoring its power over war and impeachment, defending due process and free speech, backing Ukraine against Russia, and honoring the inclusive spirit of James Madison's call for asylum for the persecuted of every faith. He concedes that such positions may sound liberal after a decade of Trumpism, and that Democrats might agree with many of them. He sees no shame in that. Parties win by acting on principle. Yet he warns that Republicans who hope to renew the party without confronting Trump are deceiving themselves. Trump has won twice, so no one should assume MAGA is finished. The writer expects a civil war within the party and hopes that every American will want a decent conservative party to emerge from it.

The column opens with a blunt claim: defeating MAGA is only half the job. Its argument is that the Republican Party, after what the writer calls the largest midterm rebuke any party has taken since at least 1974, has not learned anything from the result. The midterms were held on Nov. 3, and the piece catalogs what has happened since.

First, President Trump elevated Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff. The columnist describes Miller as, aside from Trump himself, the person most responsible for the harsh immigration crackdown, which the piece says may have alienated Hispanic voters for a generation. Second, House Republicans chose Jim Jordan of Ohio as their new minority leader. The column quotes an Ohio Republican operative, Bob Kish, calling Jordan a "backroom brawler," and cites The Columbus Dispatch's observation that in nearly 20 years in Congress Jordan has not been the lead sponsor of a bill that became law. He is, the writer adds, a regular on Fox News.

The list continues. The White House and the Justice Department, the column says, have threatened Democrats with legal consequences if they investigate corruption in the administration. The writer calls the idea preposterous and points to a Supreme Court ruling from nearly a century ago holding that the power of inquiry, with process to enforce it, is an essential auxiliary to the legislative function. House Republicans also shielded Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth from impeachment, for now, though the columnist says he violated the Constitution and the laws of armed conflict and helped plan and carry out an unconstitutional war against Iran. And the piece cites a report that Trump tried to dissuade Jensen Huang from stepping down as Nvidia's chief executive, amid reports of troubling affairs, one involving a woman suspected of being a Chinese spy.

Critics of MAGA, the writer says, can read this two ways. One is to enjoy it: a party that learns nothing keeps losing for the same reasons, so ride out two more years and collect bigger rewards in 2028. The columnist thinks that is probably what will happen, since the administration's incompetence makes a recovery before 2028 hard to imagine. But he argues for a different response: hoping the GOP comes to its senses. American politics, he says, will stay unstable until the party undergoes an ideological and moral renewal. Without one, voters disappointed with Democrats will have only populist kleptocrats and bigots to turn to, alliances will always be one election from peril, and the Justice Department's integrity will ride on every contest.

He says right-wing media have settled on an explanation for the losses: neoconservative holdovers from the George W. Bush era pushed the president into the Iran war. The prescription is to double down on MAGA and "America first." The columnist calls this idiotic, noting that Trump's approval was falling before the war and that the drop in Hispanic support likely owed much to the immigration crackdown.

He then defines terms. Trump, he says, is not a conservative, and may not even be a populist, since that implies a coherent ideology; Trumpism is the impulses of one man. People who have tried to build an ideology around him, JD Vance among them, reject what they call the dead consensus. In the writer's account, the party has grown less socially conservative and softened its pro-life commitment. It is weak toward dangerous adversaries, siding with Russia over Ukraine. It also embraces central planning, scorning free trade, imposing illegal tariffs and taking ownership stakes in dozens of companies.

His alternative is George Will's definition: conservatism aims to preserve the founding principles and institutions of the United States, including its ethos and Constitution. A constitutional conservative, he says, would return tariff authority to Congress, restore Congress's sole power to declare war and impeach a defense secretary who broke the Constitution, defend due process and free speech against the immigration crackdown and attacks on political enemies, help Ukraine hold off Russia, and uphold the founding's inclusive ethos. He cites James Madison's Memorial and Remonstrance, which praised a policy offering asylum to the persecuted of every nation and religion.

The catch, he concedes, is that after ten years of Trump even recent conservatism can sound liberal or woke, and many of these ideas would win Democratic agreement. He sees nothing wrong with that; acting on principle and doing popular things is how parties win. But Republicans hoping to revive the party without confronting Trump, he says, are fooling themselves. Democrats should not assume MAGA is finished, since Trump won twice, once after the Capitol attack. He sees a Republican civil war ahead and argues every American should root for a decent conservative party.

Conservatives simply have to, at long last, be themselves again.
— NYT opinion columnist
Jordan is a 'backroom brawler.'
— Bob Kish, Ohio Republican operative, as quoted in the column
Contáctanos FAQ