USMNT favored in World Cup opener vs. Paraguay; Eimer leans Under 2.5 goals

Paraguay isn't coming to lose gracefully—they're coming to compete
Paraguay returns to the World Cup for the first time since 2010, seeking to prove they belong on this stage.

On a Friday night in Los Angeles, the United States opens its home World Cup against a Paraguayan side that has waited sixteen years to return to this stage. The Americans carry the weight of host-nation expectation and superior talent, while Paraguay arrives with nothing to lose and a defensive philosophy designed to make that advantage feel smaller than it looks on paper. What unfolds at SoFi Stadium may say less about who wins and more about whether ambition, when disciplined and patient, can hold greatness at bay.

  • The USMNT enters as heavy favorites on home soil, but the pressure of co-hosting a World Cup transforms expectation into its own kind of burden.
  • Paraguay returns to the World Cup for the first time since their 2010 quarterfinal run, arriving not to survive quietly but to prove they still belong among the world's best.
  • Expert analysis points toward a tense, low-scoring match — the Americans struggled to score more than one goal against any opponent in 2022, and Paraguay's defensive structure is built precisely to exploit that hesitation.
  • Captain Gustavo Gomez anchors a backline with over 85 international caps, and manager Alfaro's system is designed not to win outright but to suffocate — to steal a point and call it a victory.
  • The real test for the USMNT is not whether they can dominate on paper, but whether they can break down a disciplined, low-block defense under the full weight of tournament pressure and a home crowd's expectations.

The 2026 World Cup comes to Los Angeles on Friday night, and the United States opens Group D play against Paraguay at SoFi Stadium in a match that means something different to each side. Kickoff is set for 9 p.m. ET, with the Americans listed as clear favorites — odds that reflect home advantage, roster depth, and the expectation that this is their tournament to claim.

Paraguay hasn't been on this stage since 2010, when they surprised the world by reaching the quarterfinals. That run feels distant now, but it remains the last time their supporters watched their team compete at a World Cup. This match is their chance to show the gap hasn't grown as wide as the oddsmakers believe.

The betting markets hint at how the game might unfold. The over-under sits at 2.5 goals, with the under heavily favored. Jon Eimer, a high-volume soccer bettor with a strong 2026 track record, is backing that under — pointing to the USMNT's 2022 struggles, where they never scored more than once against any single opponent. The Americans have more offensive firepower now, but Paraguay presents a specific kind of problem.

Manager Alfaro has built his team around defensive discipline. Captain Gustavo Gomez, with over 85 international appearances, anchors a backline designed to sit deep, absorb pressure, and make attacking sides earn every inch. The strategy isn't built around winning — it's built around not losing, around grinding out a point and moving on.

For the USMNT, the challenge is familiar and unresolved: can they break down a well-organized defense when the moment demands it? Paraguay isn't traveling to Los Angeles to lose quietly. They're coming to test whether American talent, under tournament pressure and the weight of a home crowd, can finally do what it couldn't four years ago.

The 2026 World Cup arrives in Los Angeles on Friday night with the United States facing Paraguay in a Group D opener that carries weight for both teams, though in very different ways. Kickoff at SoFi Stadium is set for 9 p.m. ET, and the Americans come in as clear favorites—the oddsmakers at FanDuel have them at +105 on the money line, meaning a $100 bet wins $105. Paraguay sits at +290, a significant underdog in a match where a draw pays +220.

The context matters here. The USMNT enters as co-hosts of this World Cup alongside Mexico and Canada, and the pressure to perform at home is real. Group D also includes Turkey and Australia, and the Americans are expected to win the group outright. Paraguay, by contrast, is simply happy to be here. They haven't qualified for the World Cup since 2010, when they made an unexpected run to the quarterfinals. That tournament feels like ancient history now, but it's the last time their fans saw their team on this stage. This match represents a chance to prove they belong.

The betting markets tell a story about how this game might unfold. The over-under on total goals sits at 2.5, with the under favored at -184 (meaning you'd need to risk $184 to win $100). Jon Eimer, a high-volume soccer bettor who has built a strong track record on SportsLine—posting a 31-13-2 record in 2026 with over $1,200 in Champions League profits—is leaning toward that under. His reasoning is straightforward: the USMNT struggled to score in the 2022 World Cup, never putting more than one goal past any opponent in that tournament. While this American roster has more offensive weapons than four years ago, Paraguay presents a different kind of problem.

Paraguay's defensive setup is built to frustrate. Their captain, Gustavo Gomez, anchors the backline with over 85 international matches of experience. Manager Alfaro, who runs a notably defensive system, has designed his team to sit deep and make life difficult for attacking sides. The strategy isn't about winning—it's about surviving, about stealing a point or two and moving forward. Against a USMNT team that may still be finding its rhythm in the tournament, that approach could work.

Eimer's analysis cuts to the heart of what makes this match interesting. The Americans are favored because they're at home, because they have better players, because the expectations are higher. But Paraguay isn't coming to Los Angeles to lose gracefully. They're coming to compete, to make the USMNT work for every goal, to test whether this American team can break down a well-organized defense under tournament pressure. The odds suggest a low-scoring affair, and if Paraguay can keep the game tight, they might leave with something. For the USMNT, the challenge is proving they can do what they couldn't in 2022: finish their chances and control a match from start to finish.

Paraguay's manager Alfaro plays a very defensive style of football and will cause trouble for all teams in Group D
— Jon Eimer, SportsLine
A Conversa do Hearth Outra perspectiva sobre a história
Inventor

Why does Paraguay's return to the World Cup after 16 years matter so much to this match?

Model

Because they're not here just to participate. They made the quarterfinals in 2010, so there's institutional memory of what's possible. That changes how they approach a game like this—they're not intimidated, they're hungry.

Inventor

But the USMNT is heavily favored. Shouldn't that be enough?

Model

Favored doesn't mean dominant. The Americans struggled to score in 2022, and Paraguay's manager Alfaro is specifically built to make scoring hard. It's a mismatch of styles, not talent.

Inventor

What does Gustavo Gomez bring to Paraguay's defense?

Model

Experience and leadership. Over 85 caps means he's seen everything—he won't panic, won't make rash decisions. He's the kind of player who organizes 10 other players into a unit.

Inventor

So Eimer's Under 2.5 goals prediction—is that about Paraguay being good or the USMNT being bad?

Model

Neither, really. It's about Paraguay being disciplined and the USMNT needing time to find their rhythm. First matches are always tight. Add a defensive opponent, and you get a low-scoring game.

Inventor

What would a draw mean for Paraguay?

Model

Everything. It's a point against the group favorite, at home, in front of American crowds. That's a win for them psychologically and tactically.

Quer a matéria completa? Leia o original em CBS Sports ↗
Fale Conosco FAQ