Volunteers alone cannot address rising community security threats
Shomrim, a 60-member volunteer patrol group, arrived at the stabbing scene in Golders Green within 90 seconds, helping bridge the gap until police arrived. The group, modeled on a 1970s New York organization, operates 24/7 with community volunteers trained in counter-terrorism by Metropolitan Police.
- Shomrim volunteers arrived within 90 seconds of the call on Wednesday morning
- The group has 60 members and operates 24/7 with a dedicated emergency hotline
- Two Jewish men were stabbed in Golders Green; a suspect was arrested
- Founded in 2008 in response to a wave of crimes and break-ins in northwest London
Jewish volunteer group Shomrim responded within 90 seconds to a stabbing attack in north London, earning praise from PM Starmer and Mayor Khan. Founder Steven Bak called for greater government action on antisemitic violence.
On a Wednesday morning in Golders Green, north London, two Jewish men were stabbed. Within ninety seconds, volunteers from Shomrim arrived at the scene. By the time police pulled up, the group had already begun the work of securing the area, following the suspect, and preserving evidence—the crucial minutes between crisis and official response.
Shomrim is a sixty-member neighbourhood watch organization founded in 2008, born from a period when the northwest London Jewish community faced a wave of break-ins and street crime. The group takes its name from a Hebrew word meaning "Guardians," a title first claimed by a similar volunteer patrol that started in New York during the 1970s. Another Shomrim chapter operates in Stamford Hill, in North and East London, with about forty members. What distinguishes the organization is its structure: unpaid men and women from the local community, regardless of religion or ethnicity, staffing a round-the-clock emergency hotline and responding to reported incidents on foot or by car. They are unarmed. They complete counter-terrorism training through the Metropolitan Police. They are funded by donations.
The group's stated purpose is straightforward—to help police reduce crime and give residents a sense of safety. But their real function, as they describe it, is to collapse the gap between the moment someone calls for help and the moment official responders arrive. Shomrim volunteers follow suspects. They document scenes. They hold the line until the police take over.
On Wednesday, they did exactly that. Steven Bak, who helped found the organization seventeen years ago, said the call came in that morning and his volunteers were dispatched and present within a minute and a half. Prime Minister Keir Starmer called the stabbing "utterly appalling" and thanked Shomrim, along with Hatzola, a volunteer ambulance charity, for their swift action. London Mayor Sadiq Khan praised the "heroic volunteers" and noted that London's Jewish community had endured a series of antisemitic attacks. A suspect was arrested.
But Bak's response to the praise carried an edge. He told reporters that while Shomrim was doing its part to protect the community, the government needed to do more. He said officials knew what needed to happen and should be doing it. The implication was clear: volunteer response, no matter how fast, no matter how dedicated, cannot substitute for systemic action. A ninety-second arrival time is remarkable. It is also a symptom. It means the community has learned to expect violence enough that they have organized themselves into a rapid-response force. It means they are protecting themselves because they do not believe protection will come from elsewhere.
Notable Quotes
I think the government needs to do more. They know exactly what they need to do, what they should be doing.— Steven Bak, Shomrim co-founder
Attacks on our Jewish community are attacks on Britain. Thank you to Shomrim, Hatzola and the police for acting swiftly.— Prime Minister Keir Starmer
The Hearth Conversation Another angle on the story
Why does a volunteer group need to exist at all? Isn't that what police are for?
The police can't be everywhere. Shomrim fills the gap between when someone calls and when officers arrive. In a stabbing, those minutes matter—for evidence, for catching the suspect, for stopping further harm.
So they're not replacing police. They're buying time.
Exactly. They're the first responders who aren't official responders. They know the neighborhood, they're already there, they move fast.
And Bak's comment about the government—what was he really saying?
That volunteers shouldn't have to be this organized just to feel safe. That if antisemitic violence is rising, the state should be doing more prevention, more enforcement, more protection. Shomrim is a symptom of a problem, not a solution to it.
Do they see themselves that way?
I think they see themselves as necessary. But Bak's words suggest they're tired of being necessary. They want the government to step up so communities don't have to organize their own security forces.
Is that realistic?
Probably not. But that's the frustration underneath the praise.